When I Made Him Cry
I’m pretty sure it’s like this for every highschool girl, but back when I was a senior…prom was a BIG DEAL. Days that would normally be passed by in complete ennui would instead be happily spent…finding that perfect prom dress. Not only was that damn dress especially important-along with your accessories, hairdo, and makeup-so was your date.
That introduction was a bit misleading since this little anecdote has nothing to do with finding “that dream date”. No…sadly, this is not that kind of story kids. BUT! It does involve prom…kind of.
Honestly, I bought my prom dress for $50 because it was on sale. I didn’t do anything special with my hair…left it down and combed it…and I think I might have put some eyeliner on. I didn’t really care about that perfect prom picture moment like my classmates. I actually had a ridiculously nagging obsession with something else. Although showing up to my prom in style didn’t really matter to me, what did matter to me was who people were bringing as their dates. Why? I have no idea. I was a weird ass kid.
I kept a list…of all my friends and who they were going to prom with. It was crazy. I knew who most people were bringing! All except for my one friend. Let’s call him *Mike.
Mike was one of my really good friends at the time, and he happened to be in several of my classes. Not only did we share homework assignments, we’d gossip, talk, play four square, whatever…you get the drift. We were buddies.
I heard from mutual friends that Mike wanted to ask my friend *Stella to the prom, and I immediately got super excited. Remember, in high school, I literally got off on this crap (OK, maybe not literally). Stella was the type of girl who was quiet, shy, smart, and kept to herself…she was so perfect for Mike; I totally approved.
One night, a bunch of classmates threw a hotel party. Everyone was invited. If you’ve ever been to one of these little soirees (keepin’ it classy, yo), you’ll understand when I say that hotel parties suck. Not only are you constantly worrying about the noise level, you’re also freaking out about whether or not the security will come up and bust you for underaged drinking (I didn’t take part in this). Sometimes, people get away with their night of drunken debauchery in their hotel room. Other nights, the hotel police come in raiding the place looking for unwanted guests and illegal substances. Unfortunately, that night fell into the latter category.
When the security dudes were angrily thumping on the door, everyone scrambled to hide! My hiding place of choice? Of course it was the damn closet. Oh, and guess who joined me? Mike and our friend *Fred. Both of them had a bit to drink, and were struggling to keep quiet. What happened in that closet was one of the most awkward moments of my life.
Of course, I had to ask who these guys were bringing to prom. I was glad to find out that Fred already had a date. I remember being worried because I saw him being shut down several times by this one chick…it was quite sad. After a little chit chat, I asked Mike if he had asked Stella already. I had talked to her, and she didn’t seem opposed to the idea.
Mike: Stella actually said no…
Me: WHAT?! WHY?! Are you sad?
Mike: Not really.
Me: Stop lying.
Mike: Seriously, I didn’t really want to go with her anyways.
Me: Then why did you ask her?
Mike: It was a safer choice. I was too scared to ask this other girl.
OK, at this point…I felt really uncomfortable because I pretty much figured out that this “other girl” was me from the way this conversation was heading. OH HELLS NO, I was definitely not going to ask who this other chick was. So instead, I blurted out:
Me: I wanna go to the prom with *Arnold.
Mike: ARNOLD?! WHY?
Me: He’s just so smart and sweet and nice. Isn’t he such a sweetheart?! He’s too cool.
Mike: I think he’s a loser.
Me: Well, I don’t care. I wouldn’t mind going to prom with him.
All of the sudden, I didn’t really want to know who was going with who to prom…I just wanted to get away as fast as I could. Any normal guy would have taken the hint and changed the subject. Unfortunately for me, Mike was a bit tipsy and feeling reckless.
Mike: Sandra, will you go to the prom with me?
Me: ……
Man. It seemed like ages before I actually answered him.
Me: I’m sorry Mike, I just don’t see you like that…
…and that’s when he starts bawling his eyes out. He began going on a depressing rant about how his life was awful, and how things never work out for him. I’ll spare you the painful details.
Now…if you thought that was an awkward moment for me. Imagine how FRED felt. Did you forget he was stuck in that closet too? Fred didn’t say a word throughout our whole conversation; he just witnessed all the heartbreak. After a few more minutes of excruciating silence (and some sobbing), our hosts gave us the green light to get out of the closet.
I was out of there in a flash. Fred too. I really didn’t know how to act around Mike from then on, and we were never as close as we were before.
Rejecting a guy is never a pleasant thing to do. If someone were to ask me for advice on how to avoid situations like these, I would say…don’t get yourself in them in the first place. Of course, that’s better said than done. My lesson that I took from this? Nothing really. I didn’t lead him on and I didn’t mince words. I was honest with myself and with him. If anything, I should learn a bit or two from this story.